Do you want to know something crazy? With all of my cruises and all of the port stops I have made along the way, I have never been to a cruise line’s private island. For whatever reason, none of my cruises have stopped at private islands, and I’ve never even been to the Bahamas before. I was really looking forward to seeing what it was like, especially knowing that Princess honors their drink packages on their private island! With all of the expensive excursions we had booked for the rest of the cruise, it was nice knowing that today could be totally free (or at least totally covered by our cruise fare).
My vision for today was that each cabin in our group would get off the ship at their leisure and we’d magically find each other in some central spot on the island (hopefully with the assistance of the Medallion location tracker if it worked ashore). A slight wrench in the plans came when I realized that Princess Cay does not have a pier for the ships to tie up and dock at, so we would need to take a tender to shore. My parents’ suite included priority access to the tenders whenever they wanted to go ashore. We doubted we would be allowed to mooch off their perks, especially since they were likely to be the last of the 3 cabins to be ready to go ashore with them being relatively late risers. My brother and I decided our families would meet up and take the tender together so the kids could play on the beach, and my parents would join us when they were ready.
Despite his 9pm bedtime, Ian woke us up at 7am this morning. I considered telling him to go back to sleep, but instead I just got up, got both of us dressed, and took him upstairs to the buffet for breakfast while Jason slept in a little later. I have sort of figured out the logistics of managing taking Ian to the buffet when it’s just the two of us: I take 2 empty plates and keep them stacked together, and put all of our food onto one plate, then when we sit down at the table, I divide it up into separate plates. This would have been a lot easier to manage if Princess didn’t use such extremely heavy plates though! I understand they want them to be durable, but plastic plates are durable and weigh a fraction of what these ceramic plates weighed!
We grabbed a table next to the window to admire the view while we ate. In the distance, I noticed a cruise ship docked at an island. It was only 8am at this point, and we weren’t due to arrive at Princess Cays for another hour, so I assumed it was a ship from a different cruise line docked at a private island adjacent to Princess Cays.
One of the waiters stopped at our table to ask if we wanted coffee, water, or juice, and I asked him about that ship. He said it was another Princess ship at Princess Cay. That didn’t sound correct to me because firstly, that ship was docked and I already knew Princess Cay does not have a dock, and secondly, I had looked up the cruise ship schedule for all of our ports and this was the one time I knew we would not have any other ships in port with us.
As we got closer, I saw the ship had 2 red funnels, which meant it definitely was not a Princess ship. When we were sailing past it, I could clearly see the Mickey heads on the 2 funnels, so now I knew it was a Disney ship and they were docked at their own private island! Whew! I hoped that meant that my research was correct and we would have Princess Cay all to ourselves today.
When we finished eating, we went up to deck 17 for a better view of the Disney ship.
While we were up there, Jason texted me that he was awake, so we met him back down in the buffet. We ran into my brother’s family, so we all sat together while they ate breakfast. My brother did not want to deal with waiting in line for tender tickets, so he wanted to stay on the ship a little longer and get off when the initial rush died down. I didn’t see any purpose in twiddling my thumbs on the ship, so I said I would get tender tickets for my cabin, and we would go ashore first and find seats for the group, then my brother planned to find us a little later.
As instructed on the information left in our cabin, we went down to the Sushi Bar on Deck 6 to get tickets for the tender. Only 1 person from each group had to be there to get however many tickets they needed, so Jason took Ian back to the cabin to grab our beach bags. When I got to deck 6, there was already a line of people extending from the sushi bar down to the mid-ship elevators, but it moved quickly. I watched as they handed the last tickets for tender 5 to the person in front of me, and then gave me 3 tickets to tender 6. They instructed me to wait in the Piazza on deck 5 until they called my tender number, so I went downstairs to find some empty chairs and texted Jason where he should meet me.
As it played out, we did not have to wait very long so it was a good thing that Jason and Ian were quick to find me! Ten minutes later, there was an announcement over the loudspeaker that we were safely anchored in the bay and tickets numbered 1 through 6 could proceed down to deck 4 to board the awaiting tenders. I wasn’t expecting them to call 6 tenders all at once! We were already sitting right near the mid-ship elevators, so we grabbed our bags, walked down the mid-ship stairs one level, and boarded what must have been the first tender of the day because we happened to be sitting at the right spot.
Last night, Cruise Director Tee said the tender ride would take 25 to 30 minutes, so we found seats inside the boat, prioritizing shade over getting a good photo of the ship. It took a few minutes for the tender to fill up, and then we were on our way.
I’m not sure what kind of clock Tee uses, but that tender ride took exactly 8 minutes! I should have known it wouldn’t take that long because I could see we were anchored very close to the island. Maybe he meant it would take up to 30 minutes from the time you stepped foot on the tender until you got off at the island?!
Once we were off the tender, we turned left and started walking, hoping to find a map or something to guide us to where we should go. We never saw a map, but we did find an information desk. I asked if there was an area that was good for children to play, and she said to just keep walking and we would eventually see the playground on our right. Since we had never been here before, we thought that was vague. We didn’t want to get lost, but as we started walking, we realized why she was so vague. There is basically one long sidewalk that spans the width of the beach, so you really can’t get lost! We started walking in search of a place to set up camp for the day.
As we walked, we saw tons of lounge chairs on our left side lining the beach, and then we found the children’s play area on the right side where the lady said it would be. There was a small swimming pool with a few lounge chairs with umbrellas, but there weren’t very many of them and it looked like those were meant for parents whose kids were actively swimming at that time.
Next to the pool, there was a large playground that looked like a lot of fun for the kids and we decided we would come back here later in the day when my brother’s family joined us so Ian would have kids to play with.
There was also a separate shaded area with adirondack chairs and giant foam pieces to build and play with. Ian actually had those same blue foam pieces at his daycare from when he was younger, so he was familiar with them.
We decided not to set up camp at the play area, and kept walking along the path to find our perfect spot for the day. We wanted to get further down, away from where the tenders drop you off, in hopes it wouldn’t be as crowded. We saw the place where they would serve lunch later in the day. Just behind that were lots of big picnic tables under shade structures, which created a shadow over the nearby loungers. This seemed like a good spot for us, but what sealed the deal was when we saw the lagoon! The beach in this area was protected by a jetty, and that created a lagoon with very calm water. It was perfect for the kids to play and swim, and we could easily see them from the nearby lounge chairs.
When we arrived, there was hardly anyone in this section of the island, and it really felt like we had our own private beach. We found 5 lounge chairs in the shade, so we reserved those plus one of the picnic tables right next to the loungers, and decided this would be our spot for the day. The Coconut Beach Bar was right next to our chairs, so I texted this photo to my brother and parents so they would know where to find us.
Once we were all set up, I left Jason and Ian to play on the beach while I walked around a little further into the island to make sure we really did find the best possible spot and that there wasn’t something better that we hadn’t seen yet.
After I passed a few more tents with picnic tables for lunch, I got to a section of beach with cabanas and sunbeds that were available to rent through the shore excursions desk.
That seemed like the end of the island, so I turned around to retrace my steps in the opposite direction.
On my way back, I noticed this 3 story lookout tower and made a mental note that I wanted to come back here later in the day with all the kids. I knew they would love climbing up all those stairs, and even though I personally wasn’t as thrilled about climbing the stairs, I hoped the views from the top would be worth it.
When I made it back to our lounge chairs, I was happy to see there was still hardly anyone in this section of the beach.
A few minutes later, my brother texted that he was on the tender. I wasn’t sure how we would all communicate on the island, so it was a nice surprise to see that our Princess wifi worked and we could text through iMessage like we had been doing on the ship. The medallions worked for making purchases, but not for the location feature, so I told my brother where to go to find us when he got ashore, and a few minutes later, he found us.
Around that time, I noticed the crew arrived to set up at Coconuts Beach Bar, so as soon as they were done, I went over and used my medallion to get a strawberry daiquiri. NOW I feel like I’m on vacation at a tropical beach!
There was only one thing missing… a straw! The crew said there are no straws on the island, which made it very challenging to drink this frozen drink. I wish I had known and I would have brought a straw from the ship, or just ordered a beer instead.
We spent the next few hours relaxing on the beach while the kids played in the water. I was really nervous about how Ian would get along with his cousins because he hasn’t seen them since he was 9 months old. Luckily, they got along great and Ian loved playing with them any chance he got.
At one point, my brother came over with a coconut that had fallen from one of the palm trees. He cracked a little hole in the top and everyone tasted some of the water.
As the morning went on, a few more people joined us in our section of the beach, but it really never felt crowded. It was lucky that we were the only ship in port today because I imagine it would be a different situation with more than one ship here.
Around 11:15am, I noticed that some people had plates of food at the nearby picnic tables. We walked over to the food pavilion buffet, conveniently located right behind our seats.
They must have just opened a few minutes earlier, so there was no line yet. There were 2 sides to the buffet which both had the same options… BBQ chicken, grilled chicken breast, grilled fish, pork ribs, hot dogs, and hamburgers, plus a bunch of toppings.
I got a hotdog and cheeseburger for myself. It was my mission to get Ian to try hotdogs and hamburgers on this cruise. There’s really no reason he wouldn’t like them aside from his stubbornness against trying new foods. Much to my dismay, he rejected both options and asked for a sandwich made from a hamburger bun with a few slices of American cheese. At least he was eating something with a little protein!
Just as we were sitting down to eat lunch, my mom texted to say she and my dad arrived on the island. I’m not really sure what they did all morning, but at least they finally joined us. My dad was wearing his custom Pop shirt with pictures of the 3 grandkids, so I had to get a photo of them all together!
After lunch, the kids were eager to climb the lookout tower, so Jason and I took them over there.
As expected, the kids all ran up the stairs like they thought an ice cream truck was waiting for them at the top. When I finally got up there, I was treated to a beautiful view of the beach.
While I was busy taking my photos, the kids must have lost interest in the views because they had already started climbing down the stairs. I sent Jason to run after them while I finished soaking up the views, then made my way back down. When I got to the bottom, my niece and nephew were busy picking flowers off one of the bushes.
Never one to be left out, Ian wanted a photo with me too. I tried to get one of him with his cousins, but he just wanted one with his mommy.
By the time we got back to our lounge chairs, my brother and SIL were finished eating lunch, so we all decided to head over to the kids play area for a little while. Since that was halfway back towards the cruise ship tenders, and we knew we wanted to head back to the ship early to avoid waiting in long tender lines, we decided to pack up our belongings and vacate our lounge chairs. It was now 12:30pm and we noticed the beach was much more crowded than earlier in the day. Every time we stood up from a lounge chair to grab a drink at the bar or grab something for lunch, someone came over to ask if we were leaving and if they could take our lounger. We constantly had to keep defending our turf, so it just made sense to give up the chairs at this point since we didn’t think we’d come back to this area of the beach.
We all went over to the kids area and watched them play on the playground and splash in the kiddie pool for a little while. Around 1:15pm, the kids were getting tired, so we decided to take that as our cue to pack up and head back to the tenders. That proved to be a great decision because there was no line at all and we walked right up to the security x-rays and then immediately onto a tender which was already half-full.
It’s nice that they provide shade in case people do have to wind up and down the corrals at the end of the day.
We sat upstairs on the tender so I could try to take some photos on the ride back. We had a great view of the other side of the island. I never thought to walk over there (the side to the right of the tender docks), but it looked like a nice calm section of the beach.
As we left the dock, I could see a glimpse of the rest of the beach. Princess Cays was such a beautiful island, and I was so happy we got to spend a few hours there.
I tried to get a good photo of the ship, but we were moving into the sun so the ship was in silhouette until we got close enough that the ship could block the sun, and by then we were too close to capture the whole ship in my photo. Oh well!
We all thought it was funny that we had to scan our medallions and go through security with x-rays when leaving the island, prior to boarding the tender… and then do it all over again when we exited the tender and got off the ship. Did they think we collected contraband from a passing boat during that 5 minute journey? Or perhaps someone hopped onto the moving tender to sneak onboard? I guess they can never be too safe!
Once we got through security, Jason took Ian up to the cabin to take a shower, and I went straight up to the Lido pool bar to grab us some drinks to bring back to the cabin. This time, I got myself an Elderflower and Meyer Lemon Spritz with St. Germain Elderflower Liqueur, fresh citrus, mint, prosecco, and meyer lemon club soda.
After their showers, Jason and Ian took a nap while I took my shower. In an effort to avoid waking them up, I went into my parents’ cabin to blow dry my hair, and then I spent some time relaxing outside on their balcony. So remember how we had sailed past the Disney cruise ship earlier this morning and I assumed they were docked at their own private island? Well yes, that was technically true, but it wasn’t really their own island. They were at the southern end of the same island as Princess Cays, Eleuthera in the Bahamas. The Disney section is called Lookout Cay, and Princess Cays is located just a short distance up the shore. If you had a car, I’m sure you could easily drive from one area to the other. I actually just looked up Eleuthera on Google Maps and the island is much bigger than I realized. There are several resorts throughout the island, so really Lookout Cay and Princess Cay is just a private beach, not actually a private island. The more you know!
While we were sitting on the balcony, we could see the Disney ship still docked at their pier.
That looked like a verrrrrry long pier! I just looked it up and according to Google, it is a half mile long! We could see that they had a tram running back and forth so the passengers didn’t have to walk.
Just before our 5:20pm reservation, all 9 of us met outside the deck 6 elevators to enter the Amalfi dining room together. Now that our cabins were linked, they had no trouble assigning us to the same table where we sat last night.
I ordered the fried mushrooms and the crab seafood cocktail appetizers, followed by the pork belly entree. Everything was served at the appropriate temperatures and tasted delicious.
Unfortunately, service was incredibly slow tonight. My appetizers were served at 5:55pm (35 minutes after we were seated), and my entree was served at 6:20pm. None of us wanted to wait around to order our desserts and wait for them to be served, and my brother was eager to head to the theater for the 7pm production show, so we all opted to skip dessert and grab something later from the buffet if we wanted it.
We dropped off Ian at camp when they opened at 7pm. On last year’s cruise, the shows were at 7:30pm and 9:30pm, so it worked out perfectly to drop Ian at camp when they opened at 7pm, and then have 30 minutes to walk from deck 17 aft to deck 6 or 7 forward to the theater, with time to spare to grab a drink from one of the bars along the way. This year, the shows were at 7pm and 9pm, so it was impossible for us to catch the start of the 7pm show. I wish the camp coordinated their timing better with the evening shows because we weren’t the only parents facing this dilemma. We had a similar issue on our Carnival cruise this summer, but they accommodated us by letting us drop off Ian a few minutes early, plus the camp was at the forward elevators, so it was an easy journey straight down to get to the theater. On this cruise, we had to walk the entire length of the ship to get from camp to the theater, so in the end, we decided it was easier to watch the 9pm shows most nights, even if that meant we couldn’t sit with my brother’s family.
Tonight, there was a 7:15pm comedy show in the Vista Lounge, so that worked out well with our logistics. We took the aft elevators straight down from camp at deck 17 to the Vista Lounge on deck 7, and found seats for us and my parents. We even had a few minutes to spare so Jason could grab us some drinks before the show started. Tonight’s comedian was Brandon Vestal, and Jason and I both found his dry, subdued jokes very funny. I kept looking over at my parents and I could tell they didn’t find it funny at all. I guess everyone has the right to their own opinions!
After the comedy show, I went up to the Bellini Bar for a Tropical Bellini, with Bacardi Superior, Prosecco, agave, and lime, while Jason got us seats in Princess Live for the 8pm trivia game.
The trivia game was sort of like Jeopardy style, with 5 categories, and each category had 5 different questions. I forgot to write down the categories in my notes, but it was definitely tricky and I think we only knew a few of the answers. It was fun to play along, but we left a little early to find seats in the theater for the 9pm production show.
Tonight’s show was Spotlight Bar, which was our favorite show from last year’s cruise. We enjoyed it just as much this year! It was set in a local neighborhood bar from opening to closing time one night, and the patrons visiting the bar sang familiar pop songs to share stories about their lives. I really enjoyed the song choices and choreography. It featured “Brave” and “She Used To Be Mine” by Sara Bareilles, “Havana” by Camila Cabello, “Don’t You Worry ‘Bout A Thing” by Stevie Wonder, and “When I Was Your Man” by Bruno Mars. There were 2 songs that I found particularly entertaining. They sang “Old Town Road” by Lil Nas X, and the choreography featured the male dancers dressed like cowboys, dancing a country line dance on top of the restaurant tables. I also really enjoyed when they sang “Haven’t Met You Yet” by Michael Buble because it was from the perspective of a girl meeting a bunch of first dates from a dating app. Each man acted out a stereotypically bad first date behavior, until the last guy came out and was a perfect gentleman. They stayed together for the rest of the show, and as the patrons left the bar at the end of the night, that couple left together. It was very clever, and I appreciated the creativity.
I tried to take photos throughout the show, but the 5x zoom on my iPhone was no match for how far back we were sitting in the theater.
The show ended at 9:45pm, giving us just enough time to walk across the ship once again and take the aft elevators up to deck 17 to pick up Ian from camp before they closed at 10pm. We all went back to the cabin to get ready for bed. There was a paper on our bed reminding us to set our clocks ahead one hour tonight, so by the time we got ready for bed, we went to sleep around midnight on the new time. Conveniently, tomorrow would be a sea day when we had no need to wake up early!
Today’s drinks total: 22
Up next: our first sea day







































































































































































































































































































































































































































